Back to the journal

How we get our pancakes that fluffy

The secret isn't fancy — it's buttermilk, a gentle hand, and knowing exactly when to stop whisking. Here's how we do it on the flat-top every morning.

RecipeCafe life
MaraCo-founder & kitchenJune 21, 2026 · 2 min read
How we get our pancakes that fluffy

People ask us about the pancakes more than anything else on the menu. There's no single trick — it's a handful of small habits that add up to a tall, cloud-soft stack. None of them are complicated, and all of them work just as well at home.

Start with the batter

Everything good about a pancake is decided before it ever touches the pan. Get the batter right and the rest is mostly patience.

Buttermilk does the heavy lifting

The acidity in buttermilk reacts with the baking soda to give you lift, and it keeps the crumb tender. It's the one ingredient we'd never swap — you can taste the difference in the Sunrise Stack straight away.

No buttermilk on hand?

Stir a tablespoon of lemon juice into regular milk and let it sit for ten minutes. It's not quite the same, but it's close enough for a lazy Sunday.

Our four non-negotiables

  1. Buttermilk, always. The lift and the tender crumb both come from here.
  2. Stop whisking too soon. Mix until the dry streaks just vanish — lumps are a good sign.
  3. Let it rest. Ten to fifteen minutes so the flour hydrates and the bubbles settle.
  4. Patience at the pan. Medium heat, wait for bubbles, and only ever flip once.

Lumps in the batter aren't a mistake — they're the difference between a pancake and a hockey puck.

At the pan

A medium, steady heat beats a hot pan every time. Wait for bubbles to form and pop across the surface before you flip — rushing it is the single most common mistake we see.

The checklist we live by

  • Medium heat, lightly buttered — not greasy.
  • Wait for bubbles, then flip once and leave it be.
  • Keep them warm in a low oven while you finish the batch.

One last thing

That's the whole secret. Good buttermilk, a light touch, a little rest, and patience at the pan. Come try a stack and see for yourself — find us on Maple Street any morning.

Filed underRecipeCafe life
Written byMara

Pancake purist. Will not be rushed on the hollandaise, and whisks the batter by hand every single morning.